January 12th, 2015
Reflection –
Peterson, Atwell
An interesting theme that came up
in both of the readings this week was the idea that all teachers should aim “to
make sure that our students learn to communicate through writing” (Peterson,
2). Peterson discusses the challenges that teachers face in trying to find time
to teach writing within specific content areas. I agree with her belief that
writing should be taught within each and every content area. The burden of
teaching writing should not fall solely on teachers of English and language
arts. These teachers have their own curriculum expectations to meet, and on top
of that, they are really only able to teach writing in relation to one content
area: English.
It is unfair to assign the task of
teaching writing solely to English teachers, because students need to learn how
to write according to the conventions of various genres across different
content areas. In order to get this point across, Peterson uses the example of
learning how to write something like a lab report in science. This is of course
a genre of writing that is essential to writing in the sciences, but also a
genre that would never be found in an English course. The point is that the
English teacher should not be responsible for teaching writing in general, as
if writing were a singular attainable skill.
No comments:
Post a Comment